We must build a new policy framework
for a fair, sustainable, and healthy food system.
“There
is absolutely no way to explain this other than agriculture is just not a
priority,” said Senate Agriculture Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow on the
Senate Floor on New Year’s Day.
She
was describing the bare-bones Farm Bill extension agreed to as part of the
stop-gap budget deal.
Most
astonishing was how Congress and the White House seemed to ignore the
longstanding importance of this legislation when they failed to provide
mandatory funding for a whole host of programs in the absence of its full
renewal.
The Farm Bill is the nation’s largest piece of agricultural legislation. It’s the usual vehicle for far-reaching programs to boost crop production, protect farmers, advance rural development, conserve energy, provide for international food aid, and, notably, run nutrition assistance programs. And it’s in limbo.
This
stripped-down extension came just after the House allowed the Farm Bill to
expire, never even calling for a vote. House Speaker John Boehner simply didn’t
bother. He clearly didn’t pay any political cost for that — he was overwhelmingly
reelected as House Speaker shortly thereafter.
Is
this the end of the Farm Bill? Collin Peterson, the ranking Democrat on the House Agriculture Committee, seems
to think so.
The
Minnesota lawmaker has written House leadership asking for an agreement to
bring a Farm Bill to a vote if it comes out of committee — otherwise, he just
won’t bother writing one. As importantly, he asks whether their plan is simply
to renew the Farm Bill (rather than actually writing the traditional five-year
bill) and look for ways to scale back the bill each year.
The
reality is that this key legislation has drifted a long way from its original
form passed during the Great Depression. Back then, it was called the
Agricultural Adjustment Act. Originally, it was designed to address the
oversupply of agricultural commodities while ensuring that the marketplace paid
farmers a fair price.
Now,
managing supply and stabilizing prices for farmers and consumers — despite
evidence of enormous taxpayer savings — isn’t a priority in Washington.
The modern-day Farm Bill, while having many good programs, virtually ignores the biggest and most pressing challenges in agriculture: wild market volatility that threatens financial stability for farmers and access for consumers, climate-induced droughts and floods, and the increasing monopoly power of corporations.
Nor does it address major problems of the food system as a whole, such as the health crisis associated with childhood obesity or the exploitation of workers all along the food chain.
The modern-day Farm Bill, while having many good programs, virtually ignores the biggest and most pressing challenges in agriculture: wild market volatility that threatens financial stability for farmers and access for consumers, climate-induced droughts and floods, and the increasing monopoly power of corporations.
Nor does it address major problems of the food system as a whole, such as the health crisis associated with childhood obesity or the exploitation of workers all along the food chain.
Instead
of acting as a vehicle for real reform, Congress has made it clear that the
Farm Bill will be, in essence, a step down from the status quo. The
skeletal structure stays in place as it’s bled by a thousand budget cuts.
It’s
time we pay attention to the messages Congress is sending and begin to look
beyond the Farm Bill to build a new policy framework for a fair, sustainable,
and healthy food system.
We
need policies — many of which are starting to appear at the community and state
level, rather than out of the bumbling federal framework — that get to the
heart of the challenges farmers face. We need fair and transparent pricing,
adequate insurance programs, financing options for farmers or food business
operators, and fair competition in the marketplace. We need our labor laws to
catch up with the challenges of farm workers, food processing workers, and
those working in restaurants and supermarkets.
In
the short term, we can’t forget the important programs the Farm Bill funds. But
real change will require a new approach that values the needs of farmers and
society as a whole over the demands of corporations.
Jim Harkness is the president of the Institute
for Agriculture and Trade Policy. www.iatp.org
Distributed via OtherWords (OtherWords.org)
Distributed via OtherWords (OtherWords.org)