Association for Psychological Science
Mind wandering--sometimes seen as daydreaming or "zoning
out"--has been shown to facilitate creative thinking and problem solving,
but in the wrong context it can become distracting or even dangerous.
Inattentive students can get behind in class, and drivers who aren't paying
attention to the road are far more likely to end up in accidents.
And for some
professions, like surgeons or air traffic controllers, zoning out on the job
can lead to disaster.
Most research looking at mind wandering has assumed that all mind wandering is inherently unintentional, but findings from a new study suggest otherwise: People frequently report zoning out on purpose, and the causes of this "intentional" type of mind wandering can differ from the causes of unintentional mind wandering.
The findings are published in Psychological Science,
a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.
"In recent years, there has been an enormous increase in
the number of studies examining mind wandering," explains researcher Paul
Seli, a post-doctoral fellow in the department of psychology at Harvard
University and lead author on the study.
"The general assumption has been
that people's experiences of mind wandering exclusively reflect their attention
unintentionally drifting away from a task. Based on our everyday experiences,
however, it seems that people frequently intentionally mind-wander."
To learn more about the underlying causes of intentional and
unintentional mind wandering, Seli and University of Waterloo colleagues Evan
F. Risko and Daniel Smilek measured rates of these two types of mind wandering
in 113 university students as they completed sustained-attention tasks that
varied in difficulty.
"We suspect that when people are completing an easy task,
they may be inclined to deliberately disengage from the task and engage in mind
wandering. This might be the case because easy tasks tend to be rather boring,
or because people realize that they can get away with mind wandering without
sacrificing performance," the researchers explain.
"Conversely, when completing a difficult task, people
really need to focus on the task in order to perform well, so if they do
mind-wander, their mind wandering should be more likely to occur
unintentionally."
Participants were instructed to press the space bar on a
computer keyboard each time they saw specific target numbers appear on screen
(i.e., digits 1-2 and 4-9).
Half of the students completed an easy version of this
task, where the numbers always appeared in sequential order; the other
participants completed a challenging version of the task where the numbers
always appeared in a random order.
Throughout the experiment, participants were prompted to mark
their current mental state as being on task, intentionally mind wandering, or
unintentionally mind wandering (e.g., thinking about what to eat for dinner or
upcoming plans with friends).
The overall rate of mind wandering was the same for both groups,
but critically, there were significant differences in rates of intentional and
unintentional mind wandering, depending on how challenging the task was.
When
participants completed the easy task, which was designed to be incredibly
boring, they reported more intentional mind wandering. In contrast,
participants completing the challenging task reported more unintentional mind
wandering.
"These results challenge the common view that all mind
wandering is unintentional," Seli says. "Importantly, this result
indicates that intentional and unintentional mind wandering are unique
cognitive experiences that sometimes behave differently. In turn, this suggests
that researchers ought to distinguish between these two unique subtypes of mind
wandering in future work."
Seli and colleagues are interested in continuing their research
on the potential differences in the underlying causes of unintentional and
intentional mind wandering. A better understanding of why people's attention
meanders has several practical applications, including finding ways to keep
students focused during class.
"We are interested in examining the causes and consequences
of unintentional and intentional mind wandering in educational settings,"
they write. "Ultimately, we would like to develop methods with which
students can reduce the occurrence of these two unique types of mind wandering
so that they can more effectively learn the course material."