Donald
Trump's Speech Triggers Alarm Bells
It's official. Donald Trump is the Republican nominee for
president.
Reactions
abounded after the racist, xenophobic, Islamophobic, and misogynistic
real estate mogul accepted the party's nomination in a rambling,
hour-and-fifteen-minute long speech.
Some noted the parallels to Richard Nixon's infamous 1968
"law and order" speech; others pointed out the fascist undertones of Trump's declaration that "I
alone can fix this." Few were thrilled that former KKK grand wizard David
Duke praised the speech on Twitter.
As The
Nation's John Nichols said Thursday night, the speech
ultimately signaled Trump's "determination to exploit fears of violence as
part of crusade to seize the White House from the Democrats."
Nichols
wrote:
Richard Nixon accepted the Republican nomination for president on a Thursday night in the long hot summer of 1968 with a speech that signaled his determination to exploit fears of violence as part of crusade to seize the White House from the Democrats.
[....] The permissive '60s
would end, Nixon argued, with the transition of power from a Democratic
administration to a Republican who was prepared to crack down on violence.
"Tonight, it is time
for some honest talk about the problem of order in the United States,"
declared Nixon in 1968.
"It is finally time
for a straightforward assessment of the state of our nation," declared
Trump in 2016.
"The most basic duty
of government is to defend the lives of its own citizens. Any government that
fails to do so is a government unworthy to lead," Trump told Republican
delegates in 2016.
"When the nation with
the greatest tradition of the rule of law is plagued by unprecedented
lawlessness…then it's time for new leadership for the United States of
America," Nixon told Republican delegates in 1968.
Trevor
Timm made similar comparisons. In a column for the Guardian on Friday, he wrote:
The parallels with a man
who presided over another era in which there were widespread allegations of
police brutality and killings of unarmed African Americans seem compelling.
But if you take a detailed
look back at Nixon's 1968 campaign for president, the analogy runs much deeper
than his not-so-coded language attacking racial minorities. As each day passes,
Trump's success looks more and more similar to Nixon's rise to power.
But
the alarm bells did not stop with Nixon comparisons. On Twitter, prominent
activist and Black Lives Matter co-founder Alicia Garza said,
"I don't know what I'm watching right now but I imagine this is the kind
of speech Hitler would make."
"When
Trump says law and order what he means is shut down #BlackLivesMatter," she
tweeted. "He meant law and order for
whites, martial law for everyone else."
At The
Root, Danielle C. Belton summed up:
Trump said, "[O]ur
plan will put America first. Americanism, not globalism, will be our
credo."
Mmm, nationalism. That's
never caused any problems. I hate to bring up the "F" word, but what
a fascist thing to say, future "Dear Leader."
Black
Lives Matter co-founder Patrisse Cullors said in a statement issued Thursday,
"The terrorist on our televisions tonight was Donald Trump. He pledged to
fight for Americans, while threatening the vast majority of this country with
imprisonment, deportation and a culture of abject fear. His doublespeak belies
his true nature: a charlatan who will embolden racists and destroy communities
of color. He is a disgrace. White people of conscience must forcefully reject
this hatred immediately."
Yet
while the speech seemed "self-evidently absurd to liberal listeners,"
writes Richard
Eskow of Campaign for America's Future, "it's likely to resonate very well
among the white, largely male demographic his campaign has targeted."
Eskow
noted the rhetorical trajectory of the speech, which "suddenly pivoted
from real-world complaints" like poverty, unemployment, and crumbling
infrastructure to "something much more abstract—and nationalistic,"
something that would appeal to his "decimated" base that is
"desperate and frightened and looking for answers." Eskow wrote:
Trump spoke to their
economic injuries in classic authoritarian style:
"Not only have our
citizens endured domestic disaster, but they have lived through one
international humiliation after another. One after another! We all remember the
images of our sailors being forced to their knees by their Iranian captors at
gunpoint."
For Trump, the sexualized
image of humiliation—"to their knees"—is surely no accident.
(Remember this?)
Weimar Republic comparisons may come too cheaply, but this marriage of economic
anxiety and national humiliation is strikingly reminiscent of someone else's
rhetoric—and I think you know who I mean.
That's
what makes Trump's core message—putting "America First"—so dangerous,
Eskow says.
"At
the mention of this phrase," Eskow writes, "born of anti-Semitism and
unwillingness to fight Hitler's Germany, the crowd erupted in wild
cheers: USA! USA!"