By Steve
Rackett in Rhode Island’s Future
Ken Block’s evidence
to Donald Trump’s Election Commission Integrity meeting in New Hampshire was rebuked on Twitter by elections expert John Marion, the executive director
of Common Cause RI.
In a series of tweets, John Marion said, “I want
to share a few thoughts. Social scientists have done rigorous research on the
question of matching voter lists. Suggestions that no one has taken serious
look are false.”
Marion, who tweeted at
least 12 times on the topic, concluded about Block’s report, “You can’t take
this report at face value. Be skeptical, and read the experts.” “Unlike Block’s report,” Marion
tweeted, others “dug deeper into how elections are administered & find
admin errors likely yield false positives.”
For example, Harvard researcher Michael Morse worked with Shared Goel of Stanford and others to author “One Person, One Vote: Estimating the Prevalence of Double Voting in U.S. Presidential Elections” and concludes that the Crosscheck program, advocated by Block “would eliminate about 200 registrations used to cast legitimate votes for every one registration used to cast a double vote.”
Elections Specialist
Michael McDonald, an Associate Professor at the University of Florida says of
Ken Block that it is “Extremely troubling person with no election admin experience
asked to testify before vote fraud commission.”
McDonald went on to say that “election officials verify addresses before accepting voter registration Block could have talked to them to understand, but wild claims plays better”.
He also disputed Block’s claim that any address with a PO Box is improper. “(he) Doesn’t know that RV folks and homeless may use non-residential addresses”.
McDonald went on to say that “election officials verify addresses before accepting voter registration Block could have talked to them to understand, but wild claims plays better”.
He also disputed Block’s claim that any address with a PO Box is improper. “(he) Doesn’t know that RV folks and homeless may use non-residential addresses”.
“Matching millions of
names and birth dates across databases results in many false positive matches,
in this case claims of double voting. Block recognizes this problem, and
winnows ~60,000 naive matches to 7,271 by adding social security numbers to the
match criteria. States do not publicly release SSN, so Block contracted a fraud
detection company to append SSN5 to his list of 60,000 suspect double voters.
Even if 7,271 alleged double votes are recorded in the databases, Block does
not consider the possibility of administrative error”.
McDonald is the
co-author of earlier research which also undermines one of Ken Block’s key
claims of voter fraud, where voters share both names and birthdays. In “Seeing Double Voting: An Extension of the Birthday Problem” published
in 2008 . He says “We show that these allegations are inflated.”
Meanwhile, another
election expert, Professor Paul Gronke of Reed College and Director, Early
Voting Information Center is heavily critical of the full Government
Accountability Institute (GAI) report, which Ken Block has contributed.
”Even a cursory reading reveals a number of serious misunderstandings and confusions that call into question that authors’ understanding of some of the most basic facts about voter registration, voting, and elections administration in the United States.” Professor Gronke has also called the GAI report “sloppy and misinformed”
”Even a cursory reading reveals a number of serious misunderstandings and confusions that call into question that authors’ understanding of some of the most basic facts about voter registration, voting, and elections administration in the United States.” Professor Gronke has also called the GAI report “sloppy and misinformed”
Steve Rackett held elected office as a Green Party
representative on a district council in Watford, England (just north of
London). He won 3 terms in office as well as winning a term on Hertfordshire County
Council. He chaired various council committees and eventually became the first
Green Party member to become Chairman of the council. He has worked for various
non-profits throughout his career and has a strong interest in politics in
Rhode Island. twitter.com/Spring_is_ours and www.facebook.com/steve.rackett.writes