Update on Twitter’s Review
of the 2016 U.S. Election
 |
| This is one of several examples Twitter gave of a Russian-linked tweet |
When
we appeared before the United States Congress last fall, Twitter publicly
committed to regularly updating both congressional committees and the public on
findings from our ongoing review into events surrounding the 2016 U.S.
election.
Twitter
is committed to providing a platform that fosters healthy civic discourse and
democratic debate. We have been cooperating with congressional
investigations into Russian interference in the 2016 U.S. presidential
election. We have committed to be as transparent as possible about sharing what
we have learned through our retroactive
investigation into activity related to the election.
Since we presented our findings to Congress last fall, we have updated our analysis and continue to look for patterns and signals in data. Today, we are sharing an update on several aspects of that ongoing work, as well as steps we are taking to continue to make progress against potential manipulation of our platform.
Informing People of
Malicious Activity in the 2016 Election
As
previously announced, we identified and suspended a number of accounts that
were potentially connected to a propaganda effort by a Russian
government-linked organization known as the Internet Research Agency (IRA).
Consistent
with our commitment to transparency, we are emailing notifications to 677,775
people in the United States who followed one of these accounts or retweeted or
liked a Tweet from these accounts during the election period. Because we have
already suspended these accounts, the relevant content on Twitter is no longer
publicly available.
Updated Numbers of
IRA Accounts
EDITOR’S
NOTE: No, they’re not talking about Individual Retirement Accounts, but Russian
sites, identified by the Internet Research Agency. – WC
As
part of our ongoing review, we have identified both more IRA and automated
Russia-based accounts. The results of this supplemental analysis are consistent
with the results of our previous work: automated election-related content
associated with Russian signals represented a very small fraction of the
overall activity on Twitter in the ten-week period preceding the 2016 election.
We
have identified an additional 1,062 accounts associated with the IRA. We have
suspended all of these accounts for Terms of Service violations, primarily
spam, and all but a few accounts, which were restored to legitimate users,
remain suspended. At the request of congressional investigators, we are
also sharing those account handles with Congress. In total, during the time
period we investigated, the 3,814 identified IRA-linked accounts posted 175,993
Tweets, approximately 8.4% of which were election-related.
We
have also provided Congress with the results of our supplemental analysis into
activity believed to be automated, election-related activity originating out of
Russia during the election period. Through our supplemental analysis, we have
identified 13,512 additional accounts, for a total of 50,258 automated accounts
that we identified as Russian-linked and Tweeting election-related content
during the election period, representing approximately two one-hundredths of a
percent (0.016%) of the total accounts on Twitter at the time. However
any such activity represents a challenge to democratic societies everywhere,
and we’re committed to continuing to work on this important issue.
Enhancing
Information Quality
After
the 2016 election, we launched our Information Quality initiative to further
develop strategies to detect and prevent bad actors from abusing our platform.
We have since made significant improvements, while recognizing that we have
more to do as these patterns of activity develop and shift over time.
With
our current capabilities, we detect and block approximately 523,000 suspicious
logins daily for being generated through automation. In December 2017, our
systems identified and challenged more than 6.4 million suspicious accounts
globally per week— a 60% increase in our detection rate from October 2017. We
have developed new techniques for identifying malicious automation (such as
near-instantaneous replies to Tweets, non-random Tweet timing, and coordinated
engagement). We have improved our phone verification process and introduced new
challenges, including reCAPTCHAs to validate that a human is in control of an
account.
Alongside
these improvements, we’re continuing to expand enforcement of our developer and
automation rules. Since June 2017, we’ve removed more than 220,000 applications
in violation of our rules, collectively responsible for more than 2.2 billion
low-quality Tweets.
In
2018, we will build upon our existing improvements. Our plans include:
- Investing further in machine-learning capabilities that help us detect and mitigate the effect on users of fake, coordinated, and automated account activity;
- Limiting the ability of users to perform coordinated actions across multiple accounts in Tweetdeck and via the Twitter API;
- Continuing the expansion of our new developer onboarding process to better manage the use cases for developers building on Twitter’s API. This will help us improve how we enforce our policies on restricted uses of our developer products, including rules on the appropriate use of bots and automation.
Media Literacy and
Partnerships
We
recognize that Twitter is an important part of a larger ecosystem of how news
and information spreads online, and that we have a responsibility to support
external programs that empower our users, connecting them with resources to
give them control over their online experience.
Our
partners Common Sense
Media, the National Association for
Media Literacy, the Family Online
Safety Institute and Connect Safely, amongst others, have
helped us to craft materials and conduct workshops to help our users learn how
to process online information and understand which sources of news have
integrity. We focus on elements like verification of sources, critical
thinking, active citizenship online and the breaking down of digital divides.
Learn more about
our most recent efforts for Media Literacy Week in countries like the U.S.,
Canada and Ireland, and follow our partners @MediaLiteracyEd, @CommonSenseEdu and @ConnectSafely for
new initiatives like the Teachers Institute at Twitter HQ.
Twitter
is proud to partner with
journalistic NGOs for trainings and outreach initiatives, including Reporters
without Borders, the Committee to Protect Journalists, and the Reporters
Committee for Freedom of the Press. We will keep working with reporters,
journalism NGOs, and media organizations to ensure that Twitter’s full
capabilities are built into newsrooms and established media outlets worldwide.
Moving Forward
Even as we continue to learn from the events of the 2016 U.S. election, we are taking steps every day to improve the security of our platform and stay one step ahead of those who would abuse it. As part of our preparations for the U.S. midterm elections, our teams are organizing to:
- Verify major party candidates for all statewide and federal elective offices, and major national party accounts, as a hedge against impersonation;
- Maintain open lines of communication to federal and state election officials to quickly escalate issues that arise;
- Address escalations of account issues with respect to violations of Twitter Rules or applicable laws;
- Continually improve and apply our anti-spam technology to address networks of malicious automation targeting election-related matters; and
- Monitor trends and spikes in conversations relating to the 2018 elections for potential manipulation activity.
We
are committed to ensuring that Twitter is safe and secure for all users and
serves to advance healthy civic discussion and engagement. Our work on these
issues will never be done, and we will continue in our efforts to protect
Twitter against bad actors and networks of malicious automation and manipulation.
