For elderly residents, hurricanes bring increased risks
Natural disasters are often
particularly hard on vulnerable members of the community. Hurricanes are no
exception.
Brown University School of Public
Health faculty members David Dosa and Kali Thomas, along with collaborators at
the University of South Florida, received a $900,000 grant in early September
from the National Institutes of Health to continue their work studying the
impact of hurricanes on residents of nursing homes and assisted living
facilities.
With Hurricane Florence and the potential for major disaster, Dosa shared
insights from the team’s prior research on the effect of hurricanes in recent
years.
Q: You have studied the effects that hurricanes, including Katrina, have had on residents of nursing homes and assisted living communities. What have you found?
If there is one thing we have found
repeatedly in our research, it is the simple fact that older adults and
hurricanes do not mix.
Natural disasters such as Hurricane Florence have a profound destabilizing effect on older adults, who often have multiple medical problems including functional and cognitive limitations.
They often also have medication and nutritional needs that suffer in the days following a storm. This is particularly true of residents of long-term-care facilities such as nursing homes and assisted living communities.
Natural disasters such as Hurricane Florence have a profound destabilizing effect on older adults, who often have multiple medical problems including functional and cognitive limitations.
They often also have medication and nutritional needs that suffer in the days following a storm. This is particularly true of residents of long-term-care facilities such as nursing homes and assisted living communities.
Our research on long-term-care residents following
Hurricane Katrina and other hurricanes found that many more people died
following hurricane disasters than in non-hurricane years. These numbers were
often significantly higher than the death certificate accounts cited after the
storms.
Q: What would you tell residents of South Carolina, North Carolina and
Virginia based on what you’ve learned?
If you are an elder living in the
affected community, heed evacuation recommendations; ensure that you have ample
medication and medical supplies in the days prior to the storm; leave the area
if you have complicated health care needs or can evacuate to family or friends
outside of the affected area; and ensure that you are carrying a list of your
medications and medical issues in case you are not able to advocate for
yourself in the days after a storm.
If you are family member living
outside of the area, make sure you inquire as to what your loved one's plans
will be in case cellular phone communication is not possible in the days after
the storm. If they reside in an assisted living or nursing home, check in with
the facility to identify what evacuation plans have been made or if some other
arrangements have been made.
Q: For nursing home residents,
is it better to evacuate or shelter in place during a hurricane?
Unlike some other disasters (e.g.
earthquakes, explosions, etc.), hurricanes do provide some lead time to prepare
and make an educated decision on whether it is better to evacuate or shelter in
place for a particular facility. Nevertheless, it is a difficult decision
either way.
Our previous work showed that for
nursing home residents, it is generally safer to shelter in place if at
all possible, especially if enough supplies and staffing can be arranged for
the days following a disaster. In fact, evacuation itself was seen as an
independent risk factor for death and mortality among the large cohort of
nursing home residents we studied, even when you factored in the large number
of deaths at several highly visible nursing home disasters.
This might seem counterintuitive to
some but was not surprising to medical directors and administrators on the
ground faced with making difficult decisions on whether to evacuate or shelter
in place.
As one administrator told me in the days following Hurricane Katrina: “I had to decide whether I evacuated my residents knowing that several would almost certainly die during the evacuation and subsequent relocation to a temporary facility, or risk the fact that Anderson Cooper would be on my doorstep in the days following the storm asking why we didn't evacuate. You're damned if you do and damned if you don't.”
As one administrator told me in the days following Hurricane Katrina: “I had to decide whether I evacuated my residents knowing that several would almost certainly die during the evacuation and subsequent relocation to a temporary facility, or risk the fact that Anderson Cooper would be on my doorstep in the days following the storm asking why we didn't evacuate. You're damned if you do and damned if you don't.”
Q: What additional questions
are you and your research team exploring with your new grant?
With our new three-year grant from
the National Institute of Aging, we will study the effect of Hurricane Irma in
Florida and Hurricane Harvey in Texas on frail older adults living in nursing
homes and assisted living communities. This research builds on our earlier work
and will involve interviews with administrators at Florida and Texas facilities
to understand their experience with sheltering in place or evacuating.
We will also once again evaluate
medical claims data to assess the impact of these recent storms on nursing home
residents. Using a novel methodology that was developed at Brown University to
identify assisted living residents, we will evaluate the effect of these storms
on assisted living residents for the first time and understand how these
facilities react to disasters such as Irma.
Their new research is supported by
the National Institutes of Health (grant R01AG060581).