The wealth hiding in your neighborhood
By Chuck Collins
|
You’ve probably heard about their
offshore bank accounts, shell corporations, and fancy trusts.
But this wealth isn’t all sitting in the Cayman Islands or Panama. Much of it’s hiding in plain view: maybe even in your town.
But this wealth isn’t all sitting in the Cayman Islands or Panama. Much of it’s hiding in plain view: maybe even in your town.
America’s big cities are
increasingly dotted with luxury skyscrapers and mansions.
These multi-million dollar condos are wealth storage lockers, with the ownership often obscured by shell companies.
These multi-million dollar condos are wealth storage lockers, with the ownership often obscured by shell companies.
In Boston, where I live, there’s a
luxury building boom. According to a
study I just co-authored, out of 1,805 luxury units — with an
average price of over $3 million — more than two-thirds are owned by people who
don’t live here.
One-third are owned by shell
companies and trusts that mask their ownership. And of these units, 40 percent
are limited liability companies (LLCs) organized in Delaware.
Criminals around the world set up
their shell companies in Delaware, the premiere secrecy jurisdiction in the
United States — where you don’t have to disclose who the real owners are.
As a result, human traffickers, drug smugglers, and tax evaders all enjoy the anonymous cover of a Delaware company.
As a result, human traffickers, drug smugglers, and tax evaders all enjoy the anonymous cover of a Delaware company.
Many of these companies use illicit
funds to purchase real estate in North American cities to launder their
ill-gotten money.
In New York City, dozens of luxury towers have been connected to
global money laundering. In Vancouver, Chinese investors disrupted the city’s
housing market so badly that the province of British Columbia established a
foreign investor tax and a tax on vacant properties.
With European countries now
insisting on more transparency, illicit cash is now cascading into the United
States. In fact, the U.S. is now the world’s second-biggest tax haven and secrecy
jurisdiction, after Switzerland.
The U.S. Treasury Department’s
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) has increased its scrutiny over real estate markets in
Miami, New York, and parts of California, Texas, and Hawaii.
But that just makes the rest of the
country more attractive for secret cash — even far from big cities.
In a small Vermont town, I met a Russian investor who lives in Dubai. He was buying up thousands of acres of Green Mountain farmland.
In a small Vermont town, I met a Russian investor who lives in Dubai. He was buying up thousands of acres of Green Mountain farmland.
Our communities are being
fundamentally transformed by land grabs and luxury building booms. These drive
up the cost of land in central neighborhoods, with ripple impacts throughout a
community. And this worsens the already grotesque inequalities of income,
wealth, and opportunity.
Our communities should defend
themselves.
Property ownership should have to
pass the “fishing license” or “library card” test. In most communities, to get
a library card or a fishing license, you need to prove who you are and where
you actually live.
In Boston, they’re pretty strict —
you need to show a utility bill with your name on it. Cities should require the
same for real estate purchases.
At a national level, bi-partisan legislation from Senators Marco Rubio
and Sheldon Whitehouse would require real estate owners to be disclosed when
buyers use shell corporations and pay millions in cash. That would be a welcome
development.
Better still, cities should tax
luxury real estate transactions on properties selling for over $2 million to
fund local services. Such a tax in San Francisco generated $44 million last
year that’s been used to fund free community college and help the city’s
neglected trees.
Communities could discourage
high-end vacant properties by taxing buildings that sit empty for more than six
months a year. Cities like Vancouver have created incentives to house people,
not wealth.
We need to defend our communities
for the people who live in them, not just store their wealth there.
Chuck Collins co-authored the
report Towering Excess for the Institute for
Policy Studies. Distributed by OtherWords.org.