Our drugs in our food chain
Insects
near streams are taking in loads of pharmaceutical drugs and can pass the
compounds on to predators higher in the food chain, such as frogs, birds and
bats, according to a new study.
"Predators
that consume aquatic invertebrates in wastewater-influenced streams may be
exposed to about one quarter and up to one half of a human dose of some
pharmaceuticals," the authors wrote in the study, published today in Nature Communications.
Pharmaceuticals
are increasingly detected in waterways around the world as prescription drug
use increases. The drugs get into the water via people excreting them or when
they're flushed down the toilet. Wastewater treatment plants were not designed
to handle such contamination and previous research shows only about half of
drugs are removed by sewer treatments.
The
new study is the first to show that the pervasive pharmaceutical pollution in
waters around the world can concentrate in bugs near streams and travel up the
food chain—potentially exposing top predators to "therapeutically-relevant
doses," Emma Rosi, an aquatic ecologist at Cary Institute of Ecosystem
Studies and a co-author on the paper, told EHN.
"We've
known for a while pharmaceuticals are found in streams in places like the Great
Lakes and across the U.S.," Rosi said. "If they're getting into food
webs in Australia, it shouldn't be any different here."
"Undoubtedly
represents an underestimate"
Rosi
and colleagues tested six Melbourne, Australia, streams for 98 pharmaceuticals—including
antibiotics, antidepressants and antihistamines—and found 69 of the drugs in
aquatic insects and 66 in spiders.
"If
you go to doctor and tell them you're taking one drug they want to know if
there are interactions within your body," Rosi said. "We found 69
different drugs in aquatic invertebrates."
They
found the highest levels in those tested downstream of wastewater treatment
plants or highly populated areas—concentrations at these areas were 10 to 100
times higher than other sites.
"Insect
tissues had drug concentrations that were orders of magnitude higher than
concentrations measured in surface waters," said co-author Jerker Fick, a
chemist at Umeå University in Sweden, in a statement. "We also found a
diverse suite of drugs in spiders, indicating that drugs are passed from the
water to prey to predator, thereby exposing other animals in the food web to
drugs."
Rosi
pointed out the riparian spiders build their webs right over streams, so the
"only way they're getting drugs is when bugs emerge from streams as adults
and are eaten by the spiders."
The
authors note that the screening "undoubtedly represents an underestimate
of the diversity of compounds present in food webs because in the U.S. market,
for example, there are [more than] 1,400 Food and Drug Administration approved
pharmaceuticals."
By
looking at these concentrations, and knowing the feeding habits of predators
that eat stream insects, the researchers also estimated the drug exposure of
trout and platypus.
Rosi
stressed it's not entirely clear if trout and platypus—and animals further up
the food chain like birds—would receive the full load of pharmaceuticals from
eating the bugs, simply because we don't yet fully understand how much of the
drugs are passed on when prey are consumed.
However,
the loads could be significant, according to their estimates. Platypus, for
example, could be getting up to 50 percent of a human dose of antidepressants.
This
intake is "likely to have biological effects," Rosi added.
"What
does it mean to be a trout with more than 60 drugs in your tissues?"
It's
hard to say what the effects of these exposures might be. Previous studies have
found that drugs in streams can disrupt the timing of insect emergence, and
spiders' ability to spin webs.
In
fish, much depends on the drug, the mixture and the dose; however, mixes of
pharmaceuticals have previously been shown to
disrupt the endocrine system, feminized them, altered behavior and
reproduction, changed growth, and increased liver sizes.
There
is less research for other wildlife such as birds, but a study earlier this
year found male European starlings sang less to females that had been fed a
diet of worms spiked with fluoxetine—known by the trade name Prozac—at
concentrations found at wastewater treatment facilities.
Singing is a crucial part of courtship and reproduction for birds and such changes in behavior could cause population level impacts.
Singing is a crucial part of courtship and reproduction for birds and such changes in behavior could cause population level impacts.
The
researchers also note that pharmaceutical use is expected to continue
increasing, especially as the world population rises.
Though
conducted in Australia, the study has implications for streams and wildlife
everywhere. Many of the insects in the study—and all of the drugs—are found
throughout the world.
"What
does it mean to be a platypus or trout with more than 60 drugs in your tissues?
Are there synergistic effects?" Rosi said.
"We
really don't know."