Harvard psychiatrist breaks down the
president’s ‘severe, continuous, mental disturbance’
This
week, President Donald Trump’s former lawyer, Michael Cohen, testified before
the House Oversight Committee about his role in facilitating Trump’s potential
crimes and misbehaviors.
At the same time, Trump met with North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un. The summit failed to secure a de-nuclearization deal and Trump drew criticism when he said that he believed Jong Un’s claim that he hadn’t been aware of Otto Warmbier, the American student imprisoned in North Korea, who died soon after his release to the US.
Raw
Story spoke with Dr. Lance Dodes, a Training and Supervising Analyst Emeritus
with the Boston Psychoanalytic Society and Institute. He recently retired as an
assistant clinical professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.
Dodes
is a contributor to The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump:
27 Psychiatrists and Mental Health Experts Assess a President. His
chapter makes the case that Trump suffers from a dangerous sociopathic
disorder.
Tana Ganeva: Following what was largely seen as a failed summit
with Kim Jong Un, Donald Trump said he believed the dictator when he said he
hadn’t known about Otto Warmbier. Do you see strains of Trump’s sociopathy in
this?
Lance
Dodes: Mr. Trump is a sociopath, in that he meets every diagnostic criterion
for the official diagnostic term “Antisocial Personality Disorder.” The fact
that this is a personality disorder, rather than simply a single symptom such
as anxiety or depression, means that all his actions are signs of this severe,
continuous, mental disturbance.
To understand his actions, it is essential to keep in mind that sociopaths have only one goal: to enhance themselves, and that in pursuing their self-interest, they lack both normal human empathy for others and a normal human conscience. Cheating, conning, lying, stealing, threatening are all done with no remorse.
When
stressed with facts that would require them to admit failure, or even that
others know more or are more capable than them, sociopaths lose track of
reality, becoming delusional with insistence on the truth of what they
psychologically need to maintain their superior view of themselves. Indeed,
nobody matters except to the degree they can serve the sociopath’s personal
needs.
That’s
why loyalty is demanded, but as soon as an associate disagrees, the sociopath
turns on them with a fury; there was never a real relationship to begin with.
Mr.
Trump’s denial of the facts about Mr. Warmbier is consistent with his
sociopathy. He ignores reality, is unremorseful about lying and does not
hesitate to sacrifice the feelings of others such as Mr. Warmbier’s family.
We don’t know exactly why he lied in this case, but one possibility is that Mr. Trump has heavily promoted his relationship with Kim as evidence of his superior ability to manage world tensions and thinks that confronting Kim would interfere with that, hence personally diminishing Mr. Trump.
In any case, Mr. Trump’s absence of feelings for Mr. Warmbier or his family is the same as his absence of feelings for the disabled reporter he mocked, for religious and racial minorities, for children separated from their parents at the border and on and on.
We don’t know exactly why he lied in this case, but one possibility is that Mr. Trump has heavily promoted his relationship with Kim as evidence of his superior ability to manage world tensions and thinks that confronting Kim would interfere with that, hence personally diminishing Mr. Trump.
In any case, Mr. Trump’s absence of feelings for Mr. Warmbier or his family is the same as his absence of feelings for the disabled reporter he mocked, for religious and racial minorities, for children separated from their parents at the border and on and on.
Tana Ganeva: What made you first consider that Donald Trump is a
sociopath?
Lance
Dodes: Mr. Trump has a long history that proves his diagnosis. If you consider
the 7 traits that define Antisocial Personality Disorder in the DSM-5, he meets
every one of them:
- Failure to conform to social norms with respect to lawful behaviors.
- Deceitfulness, as indicated by repeated lying … or conning others for personal profit or pleasure
- Impulsivity or failure to plan ahead
- Irritability and aggressiveness
- Reckless disregard for safety of self or others.
- Consistent irresponsibility, as indicated by repeated failure to sustain consistent work behavior or honor financial obligations
- Lack of remorse, as indicated by being indifferent to or rationalizing having hurt, mistreated, or stolen from another.
Tana Ganeva: What’s the danger of having a sociopath in charge
of the US?
Lance
Dodes: Sociopathy is the most serious mental disability possible for the
President. Other conditions do not lead to continual disregard for the welfare
of others, lying, cheating, and repeated loss of reality under stress.
The
bogus argument made by some that Abraham Lincoln is known to have suffered with
depression, so Mr. Trump is not different, fails on this point. Lincoln’s
depression did not make him cruel or indifferent to the feelings of others,
cheat, lie, lose track of reality when stressed, or have a need to be an
absolute ruler over everyone.
There
are two major risks from Mr. Trump.
First,
there is a serious risk that he will start a war to distract the country from
his multiple failures and his attempts to become a one-man ruler. This is most
likely to occur as he is stressed by challenges to his position as President.
Other tyrants have plunged their nations into war, sometimes by creating an
international incident as an excuse, to avoid internal disputes and solidify
power.
Second,
there is a serious risk of his destroying democracy in this country. He has
already eroded it by attacking the principle of balance of powers, attacking
the judicial system and the Congress, attempting to gather all power to
himself.
He has tried to destroy our free press by claiming that its criticisms of him are “fake news” and that a free press is the enemy of the people. These are well-known tactics of would-be tyrants, and are signs of sociopathy with his single-minded concern for himself and absence of conscience or concern for the feelings or lives of anyone else.
He has tried to destroy our free press by claiming that its criticisms of him are “fake news” and that a free press is the enemy of the people. These are well-known tactics of would-be tyrants, and are signs of sociopathy with his single-minded concern for himself and absence of conscience or concern for the feelings or lives of anyone else.