Stressed
out: Americans making themselves sick over politics
University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Never-ending campaigns, social
media, 24-hour news cycles. Politics are impossible to escape, even for the
casual observer.
But are policy fights and
polarization more than a headache in the collective consciousness?
New research from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln suggests yes -- that we're making ourselves sick over politics.
New research from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln suggests yes -- that we're making ourselves sick over politics.
Nearly 40% of Americans surveyed for
the study said politics is stressing them out, and one in five are losing
sleep.
These responses and others show many in the United States believe their mental and physical health has been harmed in some way by exposure to politics.
These responses and others show many in the United States believe their mental and physical health has been harmed in some way by exposure to politics.
The research, led by Nebraska
political scientist Kevin Smith, is the first to look comprehensively at the
physical and emotional costs of paying attention to and participating in
political discourse.
Previous examinations have focused almost solely on economic costs, such as time lost from work to vote or the monetary costs of supporting a campaign.
Previous examinations have focused almost solely on economic costs, such as time lost from work to vote or the monetary costs of supporting a campaign.
Smith and co-authors John Hibbing, Foundation Regent University Professor of political science at Nebraska, and Matthew Hibbing of the University of California, Merced thought it was time for a different take.
"It became apparent, especially
during the 2016 electoral season, that this was a polarized nation, and it was
getting even more politically polarized," Smith, Olson Chair and professor
of political science at Nebraska, said. "The cost of that polarization to
individuals had not fully been accounted for by social scientists or, indeed,
health researchers."
Smith said the results, which were
published Sept. 25 in the journal PLOS ONE, are akin to a public
health crisis.
"Quite a few of the numbers
jumped out at me," Smith said. "Twenty percent have damaged
friendships because of political disagreements. One in five report fatigue. And
it's a small (proportion), but 4% of the people in our sample said they've had
suicidal thoughts because of politics. That translates into 10 million
adults."
Data were collected by YouGov for
five days in March 2017, with 800 respondents. YouGov uses a panel of 1.8
million people to create representative samples.
Because no previous studies on this phenomenon have been completed, the questionnaire was developed by mirroring diagnostic instruments used by Alcoholics Anonymous and Gamblers Anonymous.
The survey contained 32 questions in four categories -- physical health, mental health, regretted behavior and social/lifestyle costs -- and delved into how people perceive politics as the source of the problems they were experiencing.
Because no previous studies on this phenomenon have been completed, the questionnaire was developed by mirroring diagnostic instruments used by Alcoholics Anonymous and Gamblers Anonymous.
The survey contained 32 questions in four categories -- physical health, mental health, regretted behavior and social/lifestyle costs -- and delved into how people perceive politics as the source of the problems they were experiencing.
Among the other findings:
- 11.5% reported politics had adversely affected their physical health
- 31.8% said exposure to media outlets promoting views contrary to personal beliefs had driven them crazy
- 29.3% said they've lost their temper as a result of politics
- 1 in 5 say differences in political views have damaged a friendship
- 22.1% admit they care too much about who wins and who loses
"Politics is really negatively
affecting a lot of people's lives, or at least, they're perceiving that
politics is really negatively affecting their lives in deep and meaningful
ways," Smith said.
"Stress is a real phenomenon that can have disastrous health effects. If politics is a significant contributor to the levels of stress that American adults are experiencing, then yeah, it makes sense that there's a real add-on health effect from that.
"Stress is a real phenomenon that can have disastrous health effects. If politics is a significant contributor to the levels of stress that American adults are experiencing, then yeah, it makes sense that there's a real add-on health effect from that.
"If we understand what's
causing it, that can lead us to ameliorative strategies."
Perceptions of political stress
emerged more in respondents who considered themselves on the left side of the
political spectrum. Smith said this may be tied to the controversial 2016
election cycle.
"One of the things that we're really interested in is: What happens if a very left-leaning person is elected into the White House?" Smith said. "Do the symptoms stay the same but shift across the ideological spectrum?"
Because the study is the first of
its kind, Smith and his co-authors plan to re-issue the survey in the future
and are assisting scholars in pursuing similar research.
"I think it's critically
important that we push this out to other political scientists," Smith
said. "We've already handed it over to a couple of psychologists to
include on some of the surveys they're doing, so we will start to get a little
clearer picture and a little bit more traction on some of the questions we
have."