Though lacking the size and
prestige of The New York Times or The Washington Post, The
Storm Lake Times is arguably just as important.
Two years ago, the small,
bi-weekly Iowa paper (circulation: 3,000) won the coveted Pulitzer Prize for
taking on agricultural
water pollution in the state. If it weren’t for vibrant
local papers, stories like these might never come to light.
Unfortunately, all over the
country, private equity and hedge funds have been scooping up these
cash-strapped papers — and looting them into irrelevance or bankruptcy.
Here’s how it works.
Investors put down a fraction
of the purchase price and borrow the rest — and then saddle the company with
that debt.
Layoffs and cutbacks follow, which leads to a shabbier product. Circulation and revenue decline, then more cuts, and the cycle accelerates.
Layoffs and cutbacks follow, which leads to a shabbier product. Circulation and revenue decline, then more cuts, and the cycle accelerates.
Eventually the paper is a
shadow of its former self, or turned to ashes completely. Wall Street wins, the public
loses.
Perhaps the most infamous recent example was the breakdown of the 127-year-old Denver Post. Since private equity firm Alden Global acquired the paper, it has cut two out of every three staff positions — twice the industry rate for downsizing.
To add insult to injury, the
firm has been using staff pension funds as its own personal piggy
bank. In total, they’ve moved nearly $250 million into investment accounts in
the Cayman Islands.
Employees who remain grapple
with censorship. Last April, Dave Krieger — editorial page editor of
Alden’s Boulder Daily Camera — was fired after self-publishing an
opinion piece headlined “Private Equity Owners Endanger Daily Camera’s Future.”
In solidarity, Denver
Post editorial page editor Chuck Plunkett resigned, complaining that his
publishers were also censoring stories that might offend Alden.
Alden’s Digital First Media
runs many other big papers, putting hundreds of newsroom staff at risk of
censorship and layoffs. Millions of readers, in turn, may learn only what Alden
deems fit for them.
It’s not a new pattern. In 2008, a year after billionaire Sam Zell bought the Tribune Co. — publisher of the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times, and other venerable publications — the company filed for bankruptcy, saddled with $13 billion in debt in what’s been called “the deal from hell.”
After it emerged from
bankruptcy, the company was left in the hands of — you guessed it — private equity.
The march of these buyout
barons continues. This summer, New Media Investment Group (owner of GateHouse
Media) announced plans to buy Gannett. The $1.38 billion deal would unite one-sixth of all daily newspapers across the country, affecting 9 million print readers.
New Media anticipates cutting
$300 million in costs each year, suggesting layoffs comparable to those
at The Denver Post are in the offing — even as the company and
its investor owners harvest profits.
This is a crisis. This country
lost more than a fifth of its local newspapers between 2004 and 2018, while newspapers lost almost half of their newsroom employees
between 2008 and 2018.
A few lawmakers are catching
on.
Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA),
Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), and Sherrod Brown (D-OH) recently introduced the Stop Wall Street Looting Act to
curb these abuses, with Warren specifically calling out private equity firms for
decimating local newspapers.
Senator Bernie Sanders recently
introduced an ambitious plan of his own, calling for a
moratorium on major media mergers and encouraging newsrooms to unionize
nationwide.
Newspapers have been critical
to American democracy since its founding. By allowing huge corporations to gut
newspapers in the name of making a buck, we’re putting a price tag on that
democracy when we need it most.
Olivia Snow Smith is a recent
graduate of Bard College and the communications intern for Take On Wall Street.
This op-ed was adapted from TakeOnWallSt.com and distributed by OtherWords.org.