School closures, physical distancing and public health measures
have effect
Canadian Medical Association Journal
Temperature and latitude do not appear to be associated with the
spread of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), according to a study of many
countries published in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association
Journal), but school closures and other public health measures are having a
positive effect.
"Our study provides important new evidence, using global
data from the COVID-19 epidemic, that these public health interventions have
reduced epidemic growth," says Dr. Peter Jüni, Institute for Health
Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, and St. Michael's
Hospital, Toronto, Ontario.
The Canadian study looked at 144 geopolitical areas -- states
and provinces in Australia, the United States and Canada as well as various
countries around the world -- and a total of more than 375 600 confirmed
COVID-19 cases.
China, Italy, Iran and South Korea were excluded because the virus was either waning in the case of China or in full disease outbreak at the time of the analysis in others.
To estimate epidemic growth, researchers compared the number of cases on March 27 with cases on March 20, 2020, and determined the influence of latitude, temperature, humidity, school closures, restrictions of mass gatherings and social distancing measured during the exposure period of March 7 to 13.
China, Italy, Iran and South Korea were excluded because the virus was either waning in the case of China or in full disease outbreak at the time of the analysis in others.
To estimate epidemic growth, researchers compared the number of cases on March 27 with cases on March 20, 2020, and determined the influence of latitude, temperature, humidity, school closures, restrictions of mass gatherings and social distancing measured during the exposure period of March 7 to 13.
They found little or no association between latitude or
temperature with epidemic growth of COVID-19 and a weak association between
humidity and reduced transmission. The results -- that hotter weather had no
effect on the pandemic's progression -- surprised the authors.
"We had conducted a preliminary study that suggested both
latitude and temperature could play a role," says Dr. Jüni. "But when
we repeated the study under much more rigorous conditions, we got the opposite
result."
The researchers did find that public health measures, including
school closures, social distancing and restrictions of large gatherings, have
been effective.
"Our results are of immediate relevance as many countries,
and some Canadian provinces and territories, are considering easing or removing
some of these public health interventions," says Dr. Jüni.
"Summer is not going to make this go away," says Prof.
Dionne Gesink, a coauthor and epidemiologist at Dalla Lana School of Public
Health.
"It's important people know that. On the other hand, the more public health interventions an area had in place, the bigger the impact on slowing the epidemic growth. These public health interventions are really important because they're the only thing working right now to slow the epidemic."
"It's important people know that. On the other hand, the more public health interventions an area had in place, the bigger the impact on slowing the epidemic growth. These public health interventions are really important because they're the only thing working right now to slow the epidemic."
The authors note several study limitations, such as differences
in testing practices, the inability to estimate actual rates of COVID-19 and
compliance with social distancing.
When deciding how to lift restrictions, governments and public
health authorities should carefully weigh the impact of these measures against
potential economic and mental health harms and benefits.
