Now we know why Trump wants to hide his tax returns
I also pay more in taxes than the
president of the United States. And, probably, so do you.
We now understand why Trump was the
first presidential candidate since the 1970s not to divulge his tax returns.
In 2016 and 2017, the billionaire
paid just $750 each year in taxes to the U.S. Treasury. In 10 out of 15 years
between 2001 and 2017, Trump paid zero taxes.
The average middle class
household paid approximately three times as much in federal
taxes as Trump did in 2017, an average of $2,200 based on an income of roughly
$60,000. Any individual earning over $25,000 most likely paid more than the
president.
It’s not that Trump wasn’t paying
taxes at all. In 2017, Trump paid $156,824 in taxes in the Philippines and
$145,500 in India. He just wasn’t paying them to support veterans, build roads,
or protect seniors in this country.
The other secret Trump doesn’t want
you to know is that his image as a wealthy successful business mogul is a
mirage.
Over the decades, Trump personally lobbied Forbes Magazine to report that he was wealthier than he really is. Two decades of tax returns, however, reveal he is a man in deep financial doo-doo. He may even owe more than he owns.
Trump’s real estate and resort
businesses are mostly money losers, contributing to hundreds of millions of
tax-deductible business losses each year.
On top of these losses, Trump
deducts tens of millions in lavish personal living expenses — such as $70,000
in hair styling, consulting fees to his children, and mansion retreats — to
reduce his tax obligations.
Only someone with Trump’s army of
tax attorneys and wealth managers could pull off these loopholes. Trump’s
assets are spread over 500 different corporate shells, enabling limitless
shifting and gaming of income and taxes.
Trump takes advantage of the fact
that there are two tax systems in America: one set of rules for the super-rich
and another set of rules for everyone else.
Most of us get our incomes from
paychecks and government agencies that know exactly how much we are paid and
often withhold our taxes before we even see the money.
Wealthy people with incomes over $2
million and assets over $20 million get most of their income from investments,
ownership of assets, and businesses. There are endless games they can play to
manipulate their income. And they can afford to hire accountants and tax
lawyers to maneuver their taxes downward.
If you lose money, you grow poorer.
But when the super-rich create paper losses to offset their taxes, they’re
still rich. And like Trump, they aren’t sacrificing anything in terms of their
cushy standard of living.
These tax shenanigans are all the
more unseemly in the face of a pandemic that’s destroyed the wealth, health,
and livelihoods of millions. Tens of millions of families have lost jobs,
savings, home equity, and any other economic security they may have had.
They will not be “carrying over”
these losses into future years and virtually eliminating their taxes for a
decade, as Trump did.
Instead, they’ll pay income taxes on
unemployment insurance, stimulus checks, and any paycheck they’ve been able to
eke out. There will be no deductions for haircuts or consulting contracts
for their children.
Trump’s taxes reveal the real truth.
He’s more about the art of the deduction than the art of the deal.
If there’s a silver lining, it’s
that Trump’s tax manipulations reveal where the weak spots are in the current
system. Congress should restore fairness and integrity to a tax system that has
been pillaged by the super-rich.
Chuck
Collins directs the Program on Inequality at the Institute for
Policy Studies.