Controversial Education Bills Spark Heated Debate in Rhode Island
By Steve Ahlquist, Uprise RI |
| patimes.org |
Paiva was the first of 36 people who spoke out against four bills, submitted by Rhode Island State Representative Patricia Morgan (Republican, District 26, West Warwick), that represent, in the written testimony of Providence resident Jackie Goldman, “a violent and regressive attempt to vilify LGBTQI+, and Black and Brown Communities.”
All four bills submitted by Representative Morgan on Wednesday were held for further study and are unlikely to advance. No one testified, in person, in favor of any of Morgan’s bills.
“We’ve already seen how bills like these have harmed LGBTQ students in other states, and recent reports have shown that the advocates for the policies in these bills include known extremist and hate groups, from outside Rhode Island, making calculated attacks on the LGBTQ community,” testified Ryan Fontaine, on behalf of Thundermist Health Center.
The seemingly-innocuous description of each bill does not convey the full measure of their intent. The bills are aimed at undermining public education, and would criminalize the teaching of accurate history and realistic sexuality.
The bills are largely modeled on out-of-state legislation that has passed in places like New Hampshire and Florida, where some teachers have stopped addressing anti-LGBTQ and racists bullying out of fear of legal consequence, erasing LGBTQ+ students and families from the classroom, and banishing books that provide important stories for students as they explores their sense of self,” wrote Dr. Cara McDavitt, MD, in her written testimony to the committee.
The Bills:
·
H5688 would
“provide for a parents bill of rights preventing the state or any governmental
entity from infringing on the fundamental rights of parents in the upbringing
of their children. The act would spell out the rights of parents with respect
to the health, education and welfare of their minor children. Violations of the
act would result in civil, criminal and/or administrative penalties.”
·
5738 would “require
that schools develop a program for in-school suspension that sets aside and
equips a specialized learning area in each school, that is appropriately equipped
with individualized, computer-assisted learning modules consistent with the
educational level and goals of the student.”
·
5739 would “would
require that both curriculum and teaching practices in Rhode Island schools
protect and respect the civil rights of all members of the school community.”
·
5859 would “would
prevent the state or any governmental entity from infringing on the fundamental
rights of parents in the upbringing of their children.”
“One need not be a serious student of history to know that
my last name, Jefferson, was given to my paternal ancestors just a few
generations ago by the third President of the United States of America – and
slaveholder – Thomas Jefferson,” testified Leonard Jefferson to
the committee. “My intention is to remind you all of the importance of seeking,
speaking and acting upon truth, as opposed to seeking, speaking, teaching and
especially acting upon falsehoods and lies.
“It is painfully apparent that the intent of House Bill
5739 is nothing other than to prohibit teaching of truth in order to formally
indoctrinate students, as opposed to properly educate them in the schools of
this state with the hope that no one would dare speak about the elephant in
this bill.”
If the bill were to pass, said Jefferson, the General
Assembly should move to change the name of the Department of Education to the
Department of Racist Indoctrination.
Over the last few General Assembly sessions Representative
Morgan has so far failed in bringing odious right-wing legislation to Rhode
Island, but she has succeeded in helping unify public opposition to such ideas.
Can you help Uprise RI?
Funding
for Uprise RI reporting relies on the generosity of readers like you. Our
independence allows us to write stories that hold RI state and local government
officials accountable. All of our stories are free and available to everyone.
But your support is essential to keeping Steve on the beat,
covering the costs of reporting our stories. If you are able to, please support
us. Every contribution, big or small is so valuable. You provide the motivation
and financial support to keep doing what we do. Thank you.