There is not one single legal rationale to keep weapons of war on the streets of America
THOM HARTMANN in Common Dreams
He arrived at the mall just after the
neo-nazi murderer had slaughtered several people, sometimes ripping their
bodies and faces into an indistinguishable mass of flesh with his .322
ammunition.
The killer had moved on into the mall,
Steven Spainhouer was probably thinking, when he saw a 5-year-old child.
“The first girl I walked up to was crouched down covering her head in the bushes, so I felt for a pulse,” Spainhouer, who is trained in CPR, told CBS News, adding that he then “pulled her head to the side and she had no face.”
Next, he found a dead woman who appeared to
be laying across a young boy.
“When I rolled the mother over, he came out,” Spainhouer told CBS reporter JD Miles. “I asked him if he was OK and he said, ‘My mom is hurt, my mom is hurt.’ Rather than traumatize him any more, I pulled him around the corner, sat him down, and he was covered from head to toe.”
The child looked, Spainhouer said, “Like somebody poured blood on him.”
His mother’s blood. His dead mother who
will never again hold or comfort that little boy for the rest of his life.
All because a white supremacist with a “Right Wing Death Squad”
patch — commonly worn by Proud Boys — across his chest decided to shoot up a
Texas shopping center with a mass-market version of the rifle the Army
developed in the 1960s for hunting people in Vietnam.
In response to the unimaginable horror that
weapon of war inflicted on these humans, Republican Congressman Keith Self —
who represents Allen, Texas in the US House of Representatives — stepped up to
a microphone and explicitly refused to say he’d
do anything about the American slaughter:
“Our prayers are with the victims and their families and all law enforcement on the scene.”
Other Texas Republicans offered similar
sentiments. Not even one of these cowards mentioned the word “gun” or promised
to do a single damn thing.
Republican Governor Abbott minimized the
tragedy, saying, “Our hearts are
with the people of Allen, Texas tonight during this unspeakable tragedy.”
Republican Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick
might as well have spit on the corpses, asking Texans to,
“Please join me in mourning the victims of the unspeakable tragedy in Allen.”
Republican Senator John Cornyn, as he has
so many times before, ignored the AR15 that made such a quick and complete
slaughter possible, saying instead, "I
am grieving with the Allen community tonight…”
Republican Senator Ted Cruz slipped into his
usual sanctimonious acceptable-to-the-NRA word salad: “Heidi and I are praying
for the families of the victims of the horrific mall shooting in Allen, Texas.
We pray also for the broader Collin County community that's in shock from this
tragedy.”
Indicted bribe-taker
and fraudster Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton also talked like this
slaughter was the result of some sort of bizarre natural disaster, saying, “Pray for Allen,
Texas. Pray for these families and law enforcement…”
Thoughts and prayers won’t do a damn thing.
Coming from these mealy-mouthed Republicans, they don’t even comfort the
families. All they do is prepare Texas for the next massacre.
Representing the rest of America, singer-songwriter Ricky Davila tweeted a list of Republican politicians and the money they took from the NRA, adding:
“Fuck their thoughts and prayers.”
It turns out this slaughter isn’t really
all that new or unique to the 21st century. America was once before awash in
weapons of war, sparking a national fad of robbery and murder much like today’s
trend of mass shootings.
We still remember their names:
— Bonnie and Clyde gunned down civilians and cops as they cut a bloody swath across the Midwest with their full-auto .30-06 fire from M1918 Browning Automatic Rifles, semiautomatic shotguns, and .45 ACP rounds from full-auto M1911 handguns.
— Machine Gun Kelly preferred the Thompson machine gun to kill as many people as possible as fast as possible.
— So did John Dillinger, who’s famous “Tommy Gun” has been recreated and is sold online today.
— Baby Face Nelson liked to kill FBI agents with his fully automatic .45 pistol.
— Pretty Boy Floyd’s famous weapon was an automatic Colt pistol.
— Ma Barker, who as a child was devastated when her hero Jesse James was killed in 1882, couldn’t hold a rifle (she was only 5’ 4” tall) so also used an automatic handgun.
— Al Capone preferred to carry a .38 Smith & Wesson handgun,
letting his gang do the really bloody work with their automatic rifles and
shotguns.
Collectively, through the late 1920s and
early 1930s, these and hundreds of other less-well-remembered killers used
weapons developed for the battlefield around the time of the Civil War and
World War I to spill blood all across America. Weapons the Founders of America
and Framers of the Constitution couldn’t have dreamed of.
And then America said, “Enough!”
In 1934, Congress passed and President
Roosevelt signed the National Firearms Act (NFA), which didn’t
outlaw even one single gun. Instead, it put a tax on automatic weapons,
sawed-off shotguns, and a variety of other weapons of war. That’s all it took
to stop the slaughter.
None of the weapons listed in the NFA are
“illegal.” But they are under control.
I’ve legally held and fired the same fully
automatic Thompson Machine Gun like Machine Gun Kelly and John Dillinger used,
among others.
Many gun ranges offer rentals if you want
to try target practice with them: I shot them at a public gun range in
Marietta, Georgia when, back in the 1980s, I was working on my Georgia private
detective license (which I held for 2 years while writing some pretty
awful novels about a PI)
and running an advertising agency.
Most of the people shooting those fully
automatic weapons, in fact, looked pretty average, generally middle-class;
there was even racial diversity and a lot of women.
It was perfectly legal because the owner of
the shooting range had paid the tax to get the federal license.
And that’s where we can do something today
by simply expanding the scope of the weapons covered by the NFA.
To be eligible to pay the tax, you must
first acquire a Federal Firearms License.
Step one is to fill out an application with the Bureau
of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives, which you can find here. You pay a fee that can range from $30 to
$3000 (most are $200 for fully automatic weapons, a number that hasn’t changed
since 1934), provide a photo, and submit your fingerprints.
After you’ve been checked out, you’ll be
called in for an in-person interview with an ATF Industry Operations
Investigator, who will vet you for ownership of your very own fully automatic
machine gun.
There were no gun buy-back programs back in
the 1930s, and nobody went door-to-door confiscating guns.
But once everybody understood that it was
illegal to sell or possess an automatic or sawed-off weapon of war without
first getting a license and paying the tax, they simply started to disappear
from the American scene (outside of licensed shooting ranges like today).
Which brings us to a simple proposal. When
enough ethical politicians hold office to pull it off (hopefully after the 2024
election), simply amend the National Firearms Act to include
semiautomatic weapons along with the existing category of fully automatic
weapons and sawed-off shotguns.
After all, most semiautomatic weapons were
originally developed for warfare: they are, pure and simple, designed to kill
as many people as fast as possible, whether they be handguns or long rifles.
(There are a handful of “sort of” semiautomatic low-capacity rifles commonly
used for hunting; they could be exempted.)
This would not conflict with the 2nd Amendment
or even the Heller decision, as bizarre and twisted as it was, as I document
in The Hidden History of Guns and the
Second Amendment. It’s perfectly legal.
And it could take us back in time to a less
deadly America.
Fire up Netflix or Amazon Prime and watch a
few cop shows from the 1970s and early 1980s. McMillian and Wife, Adam
12, Hill Street Blues, Cagney and Lacey, etc.
Semiautomatic weapons were few and far
between back then because they were so hard to get and expensive: they were
widely acknowledged as purely for the battlefield. Cops carried revolvers, as
did criminals. Rifles were mostly bolt-action.
And mass shootings almost never happened.
Semiautomatic weapons are very profitable
for their manufacturers, and they’re the weapon of choice for mass- and
school-shooters. Most are designed specifically to hunt and kill human beings.
Which is why we shouldn’t allow them to stay
on our streets without restrictions. Let’s take them out of general civilian
circulation, just as we did machine guns back in the day.
If you’re buying a gun to protect yourself
or your home (a bad idea: guns in the home are far more likely to be used against
a resident than a bad guy), a simple handgun is convenient and
works just fine.
And any idiot who walks into the woods with
an AR-style rifle will be laughed out of the forest by actual sportsmen:
there’s nothing “sporting” about mowing down deer or rabbits with a giant
magazine and .233 ammo. (Not to mention what it does to the meat and hides.)
In fact, the groups calling for continuing
the unregulated status of semiautomatic weapons of war are mostly made up of
people actually planning seditious warfare against the United States.
Members of the so-called “militia movement”
and other crackpots believe the BS story the NRA started peddling in the
mid-1970s that the 2nd Amendment was written so average
citizens could kill “tyrannical” politicians and American police enforcing
their laws.
The reality is the exact opposite: the
Constitution itself contains numerous references to the requirement of the
government to put down insurrections and rebellions by people like today’s
Proud Boys and Three Percenters.
Every one of the 50 states today explicitly outlaws unregulated civilian militias, either by constitution or law or both. EDITOR'S NOTE: Rhode Island's laws on militias are detailed HERE. - Will Collette
Virginia, the home of Madison, Jefferson, Henry, Mason, Washington, etc., was
the first, putting into their constitution in 1776:
“That a well regulated militia, composed of the body of the people trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe defense of a free state; that standing armies, in time of peace, should be avoided as dangerous to liberty; and that in all cases the military should be under strict subordination to, and governed by, the civil power.” [emphasis mine]
Forty-eight of the 50 states have similar
clauses in their constitutions requiring any militia in the state to be
subordinate to civilian authorities: typically the governor, occasionally the
legislature, or both. (Georgia and New York are the exceptions.)
Twenty-nine states have specific laws
outlawing private militias altogether (Alabama, Arizona, Connecticut,
Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana,
Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri,
Nevada, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Texas,
Washington, West Virginia, and Wyoming). And Rhode Island too - Editor.
Twenty-five states, as the Brennan Center for Justice notes:
“[H]ave laws that generally prohibit teaching, demonstrating, instructing, training, and practicing in the use of firearms, explosives, or techniques capable of causing injury or death, for use during or in furtherance of a civil disorder.”
(They include Arkansas, California,
Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Louisiana, Michigan,
Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Jersey, New Mexico, North Carolina,
Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia,
Washington.)
As you can see from this history, the last
thing the Founders — and politicians in every state over the past 200+ years —
thought was that Americans should be armed with weapons of war to fight against
the government that they themselves created.
And it’s not like this is a new issue: back
in 1886 the US Supreme Court ruled, in Presser v Illinois (upholding state
anti-militia laws), that:
“It cannot be successfully questioned that the state governments … have also the power to control and regulate the organization, drilling, and parading of military bodies and associations, except when such bodies or associations are authorized by the militia laws of the United States.
“The exercise of this power by the states is necessary to the public peace, safety, and good order. To deny the power would be to deny the right of the state to disperse assemblages organized for sedition and treason, and the right to suppress armed mobs bent on riot and rapine.”
Back in 1907, when the Klan was the main
white supremacist militia of the day (although it operated under multiple
different names in various states), the Washington Supreme Court ruled that:
“Armed bodies of men are a menace to the public. Their mere presence is fraught with danger, and the state has wisely reserved to itself the right to organize, maintain, and employ them.”
In other words, there is not one single
legal rationale to keep weapons of war on the streets of America; if anything,
doing so is antithetical to our Constitution and over 200 years of law, both
state and federal.
It’s time to get these weapons of war off
our streets, and we have the tool to do it in the National Firearms Act.
For years I’ve suggested we should treat
guns like cars: require registration, a shooter’s license, and liability
insurance. That’s still a good idea, but we must also figure out how to rid our
towns and cities of these ultra-deadly weapons of war. This could do it.
We already have the law in place, and a
sweeping change could come across our nation with a single tweak.
Had we done this a year ago, a little boy
in Texas would still have his mother, and a five year old girl would still have
her face.
Let your members of Congress know.
THOM HARTMANN is a talk-show host and the author of "The Hidden History of Monopolies: How Big Business Destroyed the American Dream" (2020); "The Hidden History of the Supreme Court and the Betrayal of America" (2019); and more than 25 other books in print.