Flowers, backyard feeders likely provide hummingbirds with alcohol, thanks to fermenting yeast
University of California - Berkeley
The same is true of nectar-filled flowers,
which are an ideal gathering place for yeast -- a type of fungus -- and for
bacteria that metabolize sugar and produce ethanol.
To University of California, Berkeley
biologist Robert Dudley, this raises a host of questions. How much alcohol do
hummingbirds consume in their daily quest for sustenance? Are they attracted to
alcohol or repelled by it? Since alcohol is a natural byproduct of the sugary
fruit and floral nectar that plants produce, is ethanol an inevitable part of
the diet of hummingbirds and many other animals?
"Hummingbirds are eating 80% of their body mass a day in nectar," said Dudley, UC Berkeley professor of integrative biology.
"Most of it is water and the remainder sugar. But
even if there are very low concentrations of ethanol, that volumetric
consumption would yield a high dosage of ethanol, if it were out there. Maybe,
with feeders, we're not only farming hummingbirds, we're providing a seat at
the bar every time they come in."
During the worst of the COVID-19 pandemic, when it became difficult to test these questions in the wilds of Central America and Africa, where there are nectar-feeding sunbirds, he tasked several undergraduate students with experimenting on the hummers visiting the feeder outside his office window to find out whether alcohol in sugar water was a turn-off or a turn-on.
All three of the test subjects were male Anna's
hummingbirds (Calypte anna), year-round residents of the Bay Area.
The results of that study, published this
week in the journal Royal Society Open Science, demonstrate that
hummingbirds happily sip from sugar water with up to 1% alcohol by volume,
finding it just as attractive as plain sugar water.
They appear to be only moderate tipplers,
however, because they sip only half as much as normal when the sugar water
contains 2% alcohol.
"They're consuming the same total
amount of ethanol, they're just reducing the volume of the ingested 2% solution.
So that was really interesting," Dudley said. "That was a kind of a
threshold effect and suggested to us that whatever's out there in the real
world, it's probably not exceeding 1.5%."
When he and his colleagues tested the
alcohol level in sugar water that had sat in the feeder for two weeks, they
found a much lower concentration: about 0.05% by volume.
"Now, 0.05% just doesn't sound like much, and it's not. But again, if you're eating 80% of your body weight a day, at .05% of ethanol you're getting a substantial load of ethanol relative to your body mass," he said.
"So it's all consistent with the idea that
there's a natural, chronic exposure to physiologically significant levels of
ethanol derived from this nutritional source."
"They burn the alcohol and metabolize
it so quickly. Likewise with the sugars. So they're probably not seeing any
real effect. They're not getting drunk," he added.
The research is part of a long-term project by Dudley and his UC Berkeley colleagues -- herpetologist Jim McGuire and bird expert Rauri Bowie, both professors of integrative biology and curators at UC Berkeley's Museum of Vertebrate Zoology.
They seek to understand the role that
alcohol plays in animal diets, particularly in the tropics, where fruits and
sugary nectar easily ferment, and alcohol cannot help but be consumed by
fruit-eating or nectar-sipping animals.
"Does alcohol have any behavioral
effect? Does it stimulate feeding at low levels? Does it motivate more frequent
attendance of a flower if they get not just sugar, but also ethanol? I don't
have the answers to these questions. But that's experimentally tractable,"
he said.
Part of this project, funded by the National Science Foundation, involves testing the alcohol content of fruits in Africa and nectar in flowers in the UC Botanical Garden.
No systematic studies
of the alcohol content of fruits and nectars, or of alcohol consumption by
nectar-sipping birds, insects or mammals, or by fruit-eating animals --
including primates -- have been done.
But several isolated studies are suggestive. A 2008 study found that the nectar in palm flowers consumed by pen-tailed tree shrews, which are small, ratlike animals in West Malaysia, had levels of alcohol as high as 3.8% by volume.
Another study, published in 2015,
found a relatively high alcohol concentration -- up to 3.8% -- in the nectar
eaten by the slow loris, a type of primate, and that both slow lorises and
aye-ayes, another primate, preferred nectar with higher alcohol content.
The new study shows that birds are also
likely consuming alcohol produced by natural fermentation.
"This is the first demonstration of ethanol consumption by birds, quote, in the wild. I'll use that phrase cautiously because it's a lab experiment and feeder measurement," Dudley said.
"But the linkage with the natural flowers is obvious. This just
demonstrates that nectar-feeding birds, not just nectar-feeding mammals, not
just fruit-eating animals, are all potentially exposed to ethanol as a natural
part of their diet."
The next step, he said, is to measure how
much ethanol is naturally found in flowers and determine how frequently it's
being consumed by birds. He plans to extend his study to include Old World
sunbirds and honey eaters in Australia, both of which occupy the nectar-sipping
niche that hummingbirds have in America.
Dudley has been obsessed with alcohol use
and misuse for years, and in a 2014 book, The Drunken Monkey, Why we
drink and abuse alcohol, presented evidence that humans' attraction to alcohol
is an evolutionary adaptation to improve survival among primates. Only with the
coming of industrial alcohol production has our attraction turned, in many
cases, into alcohol abuse.
"Why do humans drink alcohol at all,
as opposed to vinegar or any of the other 10 million organic compounds out
there? And why do most humans actually metabolize it, burn it, and use it
pretty effectively, often in conjunction with food, but then some humans also
consume to excess?" he asked.
"I think, to get a better understanding of human attraction to alcohol, we really have to have better animal model systems, but also a realization that the natural availability of ethanol is actually substantial, not just for primates that are feeding on fruit and nectar, but also for a whole bunch of other birds and mammals and insects that are also feeding on flowers and fruits," he said.
"The comparative
biology of ethanol consumption may yield insight into modern day patterns of
consumption and abuse by humans."
In addition to McGuire and Bowie, other co-authors of the paper are former undergraduates Julia Choi and Lilianne Lee, graduate student Aleksey Maro and postdoctoral researcher Ammon Corl, all of UC Berkeley. The work was supported by the National Science Foundation (DEB-1831833) and UC Berkeley's Undergraduate Research Apprentice Program.
