Significant income-boosting potential in the sustainable superfood
by Annie Young
To help solve hunger and malnutrition while also slowing climate change, some farmers could shift from land to sea, suggests a recent study from the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University. The study was published in the journal Global Food Security.Producing and selling seaweed could boost incomes for farmers in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), particularly in coastal regions of Africa and Southeast Asia, said Patrick Webb, the Alexander McFarlane Professor of Nutrition at the Friedman School and senior author of the study.
The other authors were Natalie Somers, N23, and Shakuntala Thilsted, who works for the Consultative Group on International Agriculture Research and won a 2021 World Food Prize for research and innovation in aquaculture and food systems. The team reviewed research papers, existing databases, United Nations and World Bank Group reports, and more.
A more sustainable alternative to raising
livestock, seaweed cultivation requires no land, freshwater, or chemical
fertilizers, and could become particularly profitable as demand for
nutrient-rich seaweed products grows around the world, the study found. Those
profits would mean more buying power for those households and communities who
produce, process, package, and export the microalgae, which in turn would
translate into healthier diets.
“One of the biggest problems of food insecurity
in LMICs is the unaffordability of healthy diets,” said Webb, who also serves
as director for the Food Systems for
Nutrition Innovation Lab at Tufts. “There are roughly 3.5 billion
people in the world who can’t afford a healthy diet even if they choose local
foods at local prices. For many of those people, cultivating and selling
seaweed would lead to higher incomes and improved nutrition through purchases
on the market.”
A seaweed expert’s take on the Great Seaweed Blob
Have you been following the Great Atlantic
Sargassum Belt, a 5,000-mile-wide mass of seaweed often called a blob, which is
quickly headed for the Gulf of Mexico? In recent months, it has posed a looming
threat to U.S. beachgoers. Many fear it will release harmful amounts of the
irritant hydrogen sulfide once it arrives ashore and starts to decompose.
In contrast to the types of seaweed the Friedman
School's Patrick Webb addressed in his study, this sargassum seaweed cannot be
harvested and eaten. “The type of wild seaweed that gets collected—standing
seaweed, if you will—gets cut from wild groves. That is healthy, because those
groves are fresh and serve as sanctuaries for fish and other sea life,” Webb
said. “The kind of seaweed that’s almost dead and just floating in the ocean?
No, I wouldn’t eat that.”
Easy and environmentally friendly
A friendly crop for both farmers and the
environment, seaweed has been grown in parts of Asia for centuries using fairly
simple techniques, according to the study.
To start, farmers attach long lines of rope to the roots of the algae, which nourish the plant by absorbing nutrients from the water. Six to eight weeks later, they gather the seaweed by hand and dry it in the sun.
“A lot of what we're looking at on the farming side is not about
finding new crops or different kinds of crops. It’s about what’s already being
grown that could be scaled up cost-effectively,” Webb said.
On top of being relatively easy to grow, seaweed
has a miniscule carbon footprint, and may even help lower the ocean’s carbon
levels. Though little is yet known about how much CO2 seaweed releases during harvest, research has
found that perennial brown algae farms absorb up to ten tons of CO2 per hectare of sea
surface per year. In addition to its “carbon sinking” powers, when added to
livestock feed, seaweed could help dramatically reduce methane gas emissions.
“Unless we get significant warming of the
oceans, cultivating seaweed offers a way that is not just climate friendly, but
climate proof,” said Webb. “We don’t know how soon the industry will start to
experience the negative effects of climate change, but the potential looks
good. By farming seaweed, it’s not going to accelerate those negative effects.
Whereas cutting down trees and adding more livestock certainly would.”
The challenges of production and processing
But while seaweed farming helps the environment,
climate change itself may present barriers to growing more of it. Ocean water
is becoming increasingly acidic, which is not ideal for growing healthy, edible
seaweed, the authors said.
Additionally, seaweed’s primary value as an
export would be for its extracts as ingredients, rather than as a sea vegetable
to be eaten whole, according to the study. And while countries with higher
average incomes that produce and export brown, green, and red seaweeds in large
quantities already have the infrastructure needed to effectively process, test,
and regulate what may eventually land on consumers’ plates, most LMICs do not.
Research into processing bottlenecks is limited,
and what little data exists on factors such as consumer patterns is owned by
the food companies who collect it, Webb said—which means governments and
entrepreneurs in many LMICs have had few resources or incentives to invest in
aquatic plant farming.
“The steps taken between the farm and the fork,
that’s what we need to focus on,” Webb said. “We need to work more closely with
governments and the private sector to figure out where the bottlenecks are and
how to overcome them.”
A bounty for the taking
If those obstacles can be addressed, the
opportunities of seaweed aquaculture are boundless, the authors said. The
industry has flourished in Indonesia, where seasonal labor is steadily
available and farms can achieve industrial-level economies of scale (in
contrast to the family-run farms of, for example, India and Tanzania).
Indonesia is now a key exporter of two seaweed species from which carrageenan,
a thickener found in nut milks and meats, is extracted.
“There are many different types of seaweed, and
they all require somewhat of a different environment in which to grow. The vast
coasts of Africa and Asia, not all of it will be prime real estate,” Webb said.
"But much of it will be.”
For seaweed farming to expand in these places,
governments must take it seriously and create food safety regulations and an
overall environment where it can happen, Webb said. Local and international
investment interest will also be key. “If it doesn’t happen tomorrow, with the
right conditions, it could happen the day after tomorrow,” Webb said.
It’s early days for seaweed production in LMICs,
but Webb is confident about its promise for farmers. “The Ministry of
Agriculture, or even the Ministry of Fisheries in these countries probably
never discusses seaweed,” he said. “What if they did? They might discover a
goldmine.”
Citation and disclaimer
The lead author received financial support from
the United States Agency for International Development as part of the Feed the
Future Food Systems for Nutrition Innovation Lab.
The content is solely the responsibility of the
authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the United
States Agency for International Development.